Should teenagers be treated as adults in the court of law

Most young offenders do not become adult criminals. The fundamental question is, are children capable of understanding the consequences of their actions? If such actions of teenagers are ignored then it will motivate other juveniles to do the same crime and get away and this would result in increase in crimes.

Should the Law Treat Kids and Adults Differently?

Juvenile sentences, in contrast, shield our youth from the unique dangers of adult facilities and preserve the possibility — however slight it may seem — of rehabilitation.

Few people doubt that the brains of year-old teens differ from the brains of year-old adults. Imagine how this plays out in the decision to commit crimes, especially in the company of peers. Simmons to ban executions of offenders who were younger than 18 when their crimes were committed.

The Court ruled that it is cruel and unusual punishment to execute persons whose capacity for control and deterrence is compromised. Or are there other factors? If teenagers are adult enough to do such crime then they are adult enough to be punished for that crime.

Hence they should not be treated with any harsh punishment rather be given a chance to rehabilitate and motivate them to take the right path. In fact, juvenile crime was already falling by the time states were tightening the screws.

Nor are the results as reliable as advocates might wish. Increased transfer has never been shown to reduce juvenile crime. Adolescents are more impulsive than adults and insensitive to contextual cues that might temper their decisions.

Otherwise there are chances of it becoming a habit that can carry on till later life of that person. As people, they are still active works in progress. Wednesday, year-old Nathaniel Brazill was found guilty of second-degree murder for killing his English teacher last year.

The only slight glimmer of hope was that Clarence might, while incarcerated, grow up and become a law-abiding adult and that we would not collectively make him worse than when he went in.

If you commit a terrible crime, you will spend a considerable part of your life in jail. And several states changed the rules to make juvenile offenders show why they should not be transferred.

Juvenile rapists should be treated same as adults

Their desire for peer approval can shape their behavioral decisions even without direct coercion. His family was destroyed. This push to treat more kids as adults, however, is contradicted by new behavioral and biological research about maturity and criminal culpability, as well as evidence from the criminal-justice system about how adult court affects children.

In case of juvenile rapists, if they have the knowledge of what insane act they are doing then how can they be treated as child or by giving less punishment does not compensate for their sins.

Experimental evidence and case autopsies show that adolescents may be prone to false confessions owing to their immaturity and collateral factors such as their suggestibility and vulnerability to coercion. Juvenile courts assumed that young offenders similarly are not fully responsible for illegal behaviors.

Our desire to ratchet up consequences is understandable. Our justice system depends upon holding perpetrators responsible for their actions.Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults?.

An opinion piece by Professor Terry Maroney. and saying so doesn’t make it so. Besides, we don’t really mean it: When we try them in criminal court, we don’t deem them adults for other purposes, such as voting and drinking.

Terry A.

Maroney joined the Vanderbilt Law faculty as assistant. Indicate whether or not you believe juveniles should be tried as adults in American courts of law.

Adolescents, Maturity, And The Law

There will also be a fine line when and where teenagers should be tried in a court of law as an adult or juvenile. Should teens who commit serious crimes be sentenced as adults?I believe yes.

We have received numerous requests from high school students and teachers over the last several weeks for information about whether or not there should be a criminal law to cover cyberbullying. Learning Objectives.

This is an intermediate level course. After completing this course, mental health professionals will be able to: Briefly discuss the history and prevalence of ADHD in adults. Juvenile rapists should be treated same as adults in the court of law A juvenile is a person who is below the age of 18 years.

The recent Delhi gang rape accused was a minor and was the most ferocious out of all, has enticed everybody’s attention.

Should teenagers be treated as adults in the court of law
Rated 5/5 based on 100 review